Pumpkin Pie: A Two-Day Ordeal

Hey everyone!

How has your week been so far? Mine’s been busy with one last midterm (before Round 2, that is), another trip to Princess Cafe, study group meetings, and relaxing evenings at home.

Before I show you the world’s most labour-intensive dessert known to mankind, let me introduce my house-mate and her boyfriend! I originally typed roommate, but some people get the wrong idea with that. We don’t share a room but live in the same “unit” where we share a nice kitchen and bathroom. But we both have our own rooms 🙂 You can take a peek into our unit by clicking here!

PicMonkey Collage

Madhulika graduated from the University of Waterloo and is currently working in the area. Arsalan, her boyfriend, is on a satellite-building team. Both of them are super kind, thoughtful, funny, and have been the best mentors for me since I came to Waterloo. They give the best advice and know this part of Ontario inside out. Plus, they are incredible cooks and an inspiration for me to be more adventurous with food!


Arsalan bought this cool ceramic pie plate and a massive pumpkin. Turns out this was a CARVING pumpkin, not a PIE pumpkin (that explains the size!), but it turned out perfectly fine.

DSC06833 DSC06840

It was sliced in half,

DSC06850 DSC06854

The seeds were scooped out with a big spoon,

DSC06862 DSC06866

And the two halves were placed facedown on foiled trays to bake. Placing them facedown helps them steam and allows them to cook faster. That’s one of the tips I learned from Madhulika! It works for butternut squash, too.


This was placed in the oven for an hour.

DSC06873 DSC06877

60 minutes later, the timer beeped and they were steaming like crazy. The flesh was quite soft and scoopable. 🙂 By now, our unit smelled so pumpkinny!

DSC06879 DSC06887

The creamy insides were scooped out and reminded me of spaghetti squash. And human flesh. :O

DSC06888 DSC06892

Unfortunately, the flesh wasn’t quite soft enough, so we discarded the skin and placed the “puree” in Madhulika’s massive pot to cook a little longer.


Half an hour later, it seemed tender enough, so we busted out a blender.

DSC06921 DSC06925

We did this in batches because the blender wasn’t cooperating, but after six or seven batches, we had lots of neon orange pumpkin puree. It was quite watery, too, but a fine sieve and a fork got rid of that problem. We probably could’ve done something with the pumpkin-infused broth (maybe cook quinoa or make veggie soup?) but ended up throwing it out.

DSC06929 DSC06931

Meanwhile, Arsalan cut the butter into little cubes and placed it in the fridge to chill. The next day, a Sunday, he added them to a dry flour mixture and cut the butter into the flour with two knives.

DSC06878 DSC06967

This takes major skill – last time I tried to make scones using this technique, the butter got too soft and I couldn’t make these big crumbs like he did. It turned out so well.

DSC06969 DSC06975

The butter “crumbles” were rolled up into a ball,

DSC06977 DSC06985

and rolled flat with a rolling pin on a floured surface.

DSC06991 DSC06996

The dough was later pressed into the pie plate,


And the edges carefully and skillfully crimped.

DSC07003 DSC07005

Isn’t this pretty? I would never be able to make a pie crust as elaborately as this. Many Chef John and Allrecipes videos were watched!


The filling involved eggs and egg yolks, along with numerous spices. I think pumpkin pie spice smells like Homesense, the department store! Or maybe Bath and Body Works candles. Does pumpkin pie spice have a non-food smell to you?

DSC07011 DSC07013

All whisked up with some sweetened condensed milk and poured into the chilled pie crust.

DSC07018 DSC07022

This was supposed to be done in an hour, but ours took closer to an hour and 45 minutes. After letting it cool at room temperature, we chilled it in the fridge overnight and devoured it the next day!

DSC07040 12182077_10153135021611631_601562996_n

Before serving, Madhulika whisked up some heavy cream (BY HAND!) with a tablespoon of white sugar and a teaspoon or so of vanilla extract. It turned out so fluffy. There is nothing quite like fresh whipped cream! Then, I wanted some chopped nuts for additional texture on my pie, so Madhulika helped me crush them using the legs of a chair 🙂

DSC07087 DSC07090

“I need to practice putting on a sexy dollop.” – Arsalan, putting dollops of whipped cream on three slices of pie

This one turned out the sexiest and was sprinkled with cinnamon before we gave it a photoshoot!

12179808_1086439211367853_1644321608_n 12179817_10153135021701631_732095586_n

I was lucky enough to enjoy this pretty piece. These photos were taken on Madhulika and Arsalan’s cellphones by the way! Aren’t they great for phone pics?

Pumpkin Pie from Scratch

  • 2.5 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup unsalted buter, chilled and cut into tbsp-sized pieces
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 7 tbsp ice water
  • 1 tbsp cider vinegar
  1. Combine flour, salt, and butter in a food processor. Pulse until mixture resembles coarse crumbs, about 10 1-second pulses. You can also do this with two knives, as we did here 🙂
  2. Stir water and vinegar in a small bowl.
  3. Pour half the ice water and vinegar mixture into the flour and butter mixture. Pulse to combine, about 3 (1-second) pulses. Pour in remaining ice water and vinegar mixture. Pulse until mixture just starts to come together, about 8 (1-second) pulses.
  4. Turn dough out onto a wooden surface, pat into round shape and divide in half. Form each half into a disc about 5 inches wide.
  5. Wrap each disc in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes until ready to use.
  • 2 cups pumpkin puree
  • 3 egg yolks
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 14oz can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 tsp ground ginger
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1/4 tsp nutmeg
  • 1/8 tsp 5-spice powder
  • Pie Crust
  1. Preheat oven to 425 degrees F (220 degrees C).
  2. Whisk together pumpkin puree, egg yolks, and egg in a large bowl until smooth. Add sweetened condensed milk, cinnamon, ginger, salt, nutmeg, and Chinese 5-spice powder; whisk until thoroughly combined.
  3. Fit pie crust in a 9-inch pie plate and crimp edges.
  4. Pour filling into the pie shell and lightly tap on the work surface to release any air bubbles.
  5. Bake in the preheated oven for 15 minutes.
  6. Reduce heat to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C) and bake until just set in the middle, 30 to 40 more minutes. A paring knife inserted into the filling, 1 inch from the crust, should come out clean. Allow to cool completely before serving.

My camera took some nice shots as well. Can you see how buttery and flaky that crust was? The sides were so crispy and rich that they reminded me of the massive mille-feuille that my sister and I devoured in Paris. Speaking of Paris – was that really two and a half months ago?


Covered with the professionally-prepared crushed nuts and demolished in seconds. Nothing quite compares to homemade, 100% from-scratch pumpkin pie, or any pie! 🙂 Can you believe I’ve never had pumpkin pie before this? It was surprisingly custardy and flavourful. Now I’m in love!


Many more slices were enjoyed throughout the week, and I think the three of us finished the pie in about eight days. It was just too tempting to have that plate of deliciousness calling our names from the fridge.

Screen Shot 2015-10-26 at 11.08.00 PM

I just had a slice today after lunch and it was perfection. I think pumpkin pie gets better the longer it sits in the fridge – maybe the flavours start to meld together! So by now we’ve established that pumpkin pie is awesome… but there are countless other ways to use up that liquid (?) gold! My favourite ways to cook/bake with pumpkin involve muffins, pancakes, and oatmeals, but I’m definitely going to explore some savoury options. Here are some ideas.


Ways to Use Leftover Pumpkin Puree

How do you use leftover pumpkin puree?

Awesome, right?

Whew, guys, I am so glad it’s the weekend and happy it’s Halloween! I don’t have any plans other than staying home to relax, doing laundry, and other fascinating things like sweeping and organizing my containers. I have the most exciting life and I love it 🙂

Do you have any plans for the weekend? Are you dressing up for Halloween?

29 thoughts on “Pumpkin Pie: A Two-Day Ordeal

  1. […] elegant pumpkin pie flavour. I’m such a sucker for cheesecake that this dessert DOMINATED the pumpkin pie that Madhulika, Arsalan, and I spent two days making from scratch. The flavour of the cheesecake itself was top-notch. I’d say, however, that the maple syrup […]


  2. beautiful…I did this only once….it was so much work….but it was yummy…..I have been buying sweet pumpkins and cutting them up and roasting them and the freezing them so I have bags of them in the freezer to use from all winter…yum….love all the ideas to use left over pumpkin in…..thanks…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AHAHA I know what you mean! Those impulse buys sometimes turn out disappointingly. 😦 This is a lot of fun to do with friends or family – I wouldn’t want to tackle it alone!


  3. OMG! Your roommate is absolutely a talented person! and you are a good helper too! I am glad you loved the pie so much. Waiting for two days to eat the pie was worth it. Could you make the pie for us when you come back to BC? I volunteer to help in the kitchen. I can wash all the dishes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. AHAHAHA you are so cute!
      Yes both of them are incredibly talented. I am so lucky to have great roommates, right? It was definitely worth waiting two days. Yes, if we get a pumpkin I’ll definitely give it a try! I also want to try pumpkin brownies or a pumpkin cheesecake. Yum.


  4. Gorgeous pie. You went to a lot of effort to make it from scratch. Crushing nuts under a chair leg … first time I’ve ever seen that. I would just use my meat mallet or my cast iron skillet. 🙂

    I’m not very fond of pumpkin but I wouldn’t be ashamed to put that pie on the table. Well done.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! The chair-nut-crushing was actually pretty effective! Unfortunately as a uni student who came from out of province I don’t exactly have access to a meat mallet or a heavy skillet 😉 But those are definitely more efficient!

      Thank you for your kind words. And you are the first person I know who dislikes pumpkin!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to ‘Twas the Night before Finals | Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s